| Introduction
In 2001, strength in the housing market was evidenced
by sales of existing-family homes reaching an all time high of 5.3
million units and sales of new homes grew by approximately 3% to
906,000 units. From my perspective, these results exemplify the
housing market’s underlying strength. During 2002, the housing
market continues to exhibit strength, according to the National
Association of Realtors, which during May reported that existing
home sales posted their fourth strongest showing on record.
Additional evidence comes from the Commerce Department, which
reported that sales of new homes surged to a record level in May,
reaching a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1,028,000 units. This
is the first time ever that the pace of new home sales exceeded 1
million units.
This insight will describe the market drivers that
have and will continue to provide a growth platform for the U.S.
housing market. It is my belief that the housing market will
continue to exhibit sustained growth over the next three years.
Also, this insight will touch on the housing market’s impact on the
economy and highlight some of the publicly traded microcap companies
that are potential beneficiaries.
Primary Market Drivers
It is my belief that the housing market will
remain a pocket of strength for the U.S. economy with the following
market drivers supporting this view:
Demographic: In 2002, The Joint
Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University published a report
that projects that the number of homeowners in the United States
could rise by an average of 1.1 million annually over the next two
decades, with much of the growth reflected in a dramatic rise in the
foreign-born population, particularly from the Latin American and
Asian communities. The primary impact for the housing market from
these communities will likely be for starter homes. Since growth of
the immigrant population is likely to continue, it is estimated that
minority households could rise by approximately 15.3 million over
the next twenty years, thus making up approximately 64% of household
growth.
Additional demographic factors are:
- The growth of non-family households, which
consist of a single person or two or more unrelated individuals,
which rose 11%, while single parent households increased by 8.2%,
during the period of 1996 – 2001. During the same period,
married-couples experienced growth of 2.5%. Similar growth should
occur in future periods.
- The transfer of wealth from seniors to their
children. Parents are making a significant difference when it
comes time for younger people to make the home buying decision
versus being a long-term renter. The Joint Center for Housing
Studies research indicates that as many as one in five first-time
homebuyers receive funds from a relative or friend for the down
payment. The research also indicates that many younger homebuyers
often receive financial support from their parents beyond just the
initial down payment (i.e. mortgage assistance).
Mortgage Rates and Affordability:
The Federal Housing Finance Board reported that the rate on a
30-year fixed mortgage averaged 7% in 2001, which was the lowest
fixed rate since the mid 1960s. The fixed mortgage rate environment
has remained favorable, with rates at or below 7% for a 30-year
fixed mortgage so far in 2002. My expectation is that mortgage
interest rates are likely to remain at or below 7% for the balance
of the year, primarily as a result of the Federal Reserve not
raising interest rates anytime soon. Also, I concur with the view
that the historically low mortgage rates will bode well for the
continued strength being exhibited by the housing market, since it
provides new homeowners with an opportunity to purchase a home even
though prices have risen sharply over the last twelve months.
Supporting future growth in the housing market is the affordability
trend, as noted by The National Association of Realtors™ (see table
below), which indicates that a household earning the median income
can currently afford to purchase approximately 140% of the median
priced existing home at prevailing mortgage rates:
Households Earning
the Median Income |
Median Price of
Existing Homes* |
|
2002 |
140% |
|
Early 1990s |
110% |
|
Early 1980s |
60% |
|
Source: National Association of
Realtors™ and Housing’s Rising Contribution by the
Homeownership Alliance
* Prevailing mortgage rates at the time |
Mortgage Lending Practices: It is
almost inevitable that mortgage lending practices will eventually
lead to excesses within the housing market. My view is that the
buildup of such excesses will likely occur over the course of the
next three years before it has any impact. In a report from the
homeownership alliance, it is estimated that high loan-to-value
lending programs account for nearly $1.5 trillion in mortgage debt
outstanding. This is approximately one-quarter of total mortgage
loans outstanding. The high loan-to-value programs allow lenders to
lower their underwriting standards. The lowering of lending
standards by financial institutions is currently being offset in
part through the adoption of risk-based pricing and securitization,
which should mitigate risk over time.
Economic Impact
In 2001, nationwide home prices grew an average of
5.7% from 2000 levels. This translates to some 70 million homeowners
building equity. These homeowners helped contribute to what many
economists call the wealth effect. The wealth effect refers to the
propensity of people to spend more if they have or feel they have
more assets. The data that supports the wealth effect in the United
States were gleaned from a speech given by Federal Reserve Board
Governor Edward M. Gramlich in February 2002:
- The average ratio of household wealth to
disposable income was about 4.5 from 1970 to 1995;
- Fueled by a modest boom in real estate values
and a huge boom in equity values, the wealth income ratio shot up
to more than 6 from 1996 – 2000, which is the highest recorded
value in the fifty years for which wealth data has been collected;
- Since 2000, the wealth income ratio remained
over 5, even with the retreat of equity prices, most likely due to
the continued surge in the value of housing.
The primary economic areas that the strong housing
market impacts are:
- New homebuilding;
- Home improvement and remodeling;
- Home furnishing purchases;
- Local government spending due to increased
property tax revenues;
- Improving financials of financial institutions.
The direct and indirect contribution of housing is
estimated to be one-half of one percentage point to real Gross
Domestic Product growth in 2001. According to the Federal Reserve
Board’s Flow of Funds (obtained from the Homeownership Alliance 2002
June report), households own over $12 trillion worth of housing and
have $6.6 trillion in homeowners equity, which translates to an
average household having approximately $90,000 in homeowners’
equity. The wealth that homeowners feel they have is in my view one
reason why they are likely to continue spending on their most
important asset in either making improvements on their existing home
or trading up to an even larger home.
Microcap Beneficiaries
I believe that four companies in the Taglich
Brothers’ coverage universe should benefit from continued strength
in the housing market. American National Financial and Capital Title
Group are directly impacted by the housing market as both companies
are involved in the title insurance industry, thus benefiting from
increased activity in the housing market. Craftmade International
and U.S. Home Systems are at the other end of the spending spectrum,
since these companies are likely to benefit once the homeowner has
moved into their new home or obtained money from refinancing an
existing house so that they can make improvements to increase the
value of their asset. Below is a brief description of each company
and following the descriptions is a table that provides certain
outlook and financial information.
American National Financial, Inc. (ANFI) –
Based in Orange County, California, provides title insurance
services and other ancillary real estate related financial and
informational services through its various subsidiaries, which
include American Title Company, National Title Insurance of New
York, and Pioneer National Title of Nevada, Inc.
Capital Title Group, Inc. (CTGI) – Based in
Phoenix, Arizona is a holding Company for Capital Title Agency Inc.
in Arizona and New Century Title Company in California. The Arizona
subsidiary is an independent title agency that provides escrow and
title insurance services to Maricopa, Yavapai, Mohave and Pinal
Counties. The California subsidiary currently provides escrow and
title services to the real estate industry in San Diego, Los Angles,
San Bernardino, Santa Clara, San Mateo and Sacramento, Orange,
Riverside, Sonoma, Contra Costa and Alameda Counties in California.
Craftmade International Inc. (CRFT)
– Based in Coppell, Texas, designs, distributes, and markets ceiling
fans, lighting products, and accessories to a nationwide network.
The Company, through its TSI subsidiary, distributes and markets
outdoor lighting fixtures to home improvement chains.
U.S. Home Systems, Inc. (USHS) – Based in
Lewisville, Texas, designs, manufactures, sells and installs
specialty home improvement products. The Company’s product lines
include kitchen cabinet refacing and countertop products utilized in
kitchen remodeling, bathroom refacing and related products utilized
in bathroom remodeling, and replacement windows. U.S. Home Systems
also provides consumer financing services to the home improvement
and remodeling industry through its wholly owned subsidiary, First
Consumer Credit (FCC).
|
Outlook and Financial Information |
|
|
ANFI |
CTGI |
CRFT |
USHS |
|
Current Taglich Rating |
Buy |
Speculative
Buy |
Buy |
Speculative
Buy |
|
Recent Published
Report Date |
5/13/02 |
5/09/02 |
5/01/02 |
5/31/02 |
|
Price Target /
Time Frame |
$20.15
18-Mos. |
$6.43
18-Mos. |
$21.06
12-Mos. |
$8.91
21-Mos. |
|
Price on 1/02/02 |
$7.25 |
$2.30 |
$15.80 |
$4.75 |
|
Price on 7/08/02 |
$15.88 |
$2.55 |
$14.80 |
$5.09 |
|
2003 Earnings
per share Estimate |
$1.86 |
$0.39 |
$1.17 |
$0.61 |
|
Annual Dividend |
$0.50 |
NA |
$0.28 |
NA |
|